← BCM 421 Principles of Auditing
Internal Control Systems and Audit Evidence
Notes
Fundamentals of Internal Controls
An internal control system consists of policies and procedures designed by management and those charged with governance to provide reasonable assurance regarding the reliability of financial reporting, compliance with laws, and operational efficiency. ISA 315 identifies five components of internal control: the control environment, risk assessment process, information system, control activities, and monitoring of controls. Effective control activities include segregation of duties, physical asset safeguards, authorization protocols, and regular reconciliations.
Audit Evidence and Assertions
Under ISA 500, auditors must obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence to draw reasonable conclusions. Sufficiency measures quantity, while appropriateness measures quality, comprising relevance and reliability. Audit evidence from independent external sources, documentary evidence, and original records are generally more reliable than internal, oral, or duplicated evidence. Evidence is evaluated against financial statement assertions, which include existence, rights and obligations, completeness, valuation, and allocation for balance sheet accounts, as well as occurrence, accuracy, cut-off, and classification for transactions.
Tests of Controls vs Substantive Testing
Auditors perform tests of controls to assess whether internal controls operated effectively throughout the period. If controls are proven effective, the auditor may reduce the extent of substantive testing. Substantive procedures include tests of details (vouching, physical inspection, external confirmation) and substantive analytical procedures to detect dollar misstatements directly in financial figures.
Practical example
Coast Hauliers Limited is a maritime clearing and freight logistics company based in Mombasa. The company incurs substantial port clearance fees paid directly to the Kenya Ports Authority (KPA) and the Kenya Revenue Authority (KRA). In 2023, the statutory audit firm, Wanjiku and Company, tested the internal controls governing transport expenditures and accounts payable.
Testing of controls revealed a failure in segregation of duties: the fleet logistics manager had system privileges to generate fuel requisitions, approve supplier purchase orders, and authorize electronic fund transfers. Because controls were deemed unreliable, the auditor could not rely on them to reduce substantive testing. Wanjiku and Company revised their audit plan by expanding substantive testing of details.
To verify the completeness and valuation of liabilities, the auditors independently obtained year-end balance confirmations directly from fuel providers and the port authority. Furthermore, they vouched a 100 percent sample of transport disbursements exceeding 500,000 Kenya Shillings against physical delivery notes, original KPA gate-passes, and stamped customs clearance documents. This substantive evidence allowed the auditors to detect unrecorded shipping liabilities totaling 8.4 million Kenya Shillings, which management subsequently adjusted before the issuance of the final audit report.
Quiz
1. What is the primary purpose of an auditor performing tests of controls?
2. Which financial statement assertion is primarily tested when an auditor inspects physical warehouse stock from an inventory ledger listing?
3. Which of the following forms of audit evidence is generally considered the most reliable?
Sign in to submit and securely grade your quiz.