CampusLearn
← COM 120 Academic Writing & Research

Reading academic sources critically

Notes

Critical reading means evaluating a source, not just absorbing it. BEFORE YOU READ Check the author’s credentials, the publication venue, and the date. A peer-reviewed journal article carries more weight than an anonymous blog post. WHILE YOU READ - What is the main claim? - What evidence supports it? Is the evidence strong, recent, and relevant? - What assumptions does the author make? - What is left out? SPOTTING WEAKNESS Watch for small samples, cherry-picked data, correlation presented as causation, and sweeping claims from narrow studies. NOTE-TAKING Summarise each source in two or three sentences in your own words and record the full citation immediately. Future you will be grateful. Practice: take one article from your reading list and write a five-line critical summary.

Quiz

1. Which source generally carries the most academic weight?

2. A study shows ice cream sales and drowning deaths rise together. Concluding that ice cream causes drowning is the error of…

Sign in to submit and securely grade your quiz.